Greg Stafford requests: Specifically... I would like Hartley to list the 19 Q-class nouns to which he refers on page 65 of his thesis (par. 2, line 5), for our consideration.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by Greg Stafford (205.188.200.42) on May 27, 1999 at 11:40:03
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Greg Stafford said:
Specifically, I would like Hartley to list the 19 Q-class nouns to which he
refers on page 65 of his thesis (par. 2, line 5), for our consideration. Once
that is done I am confident that the issues will be clearer in the minds of
those reading the discussion.
Regards,
Greg
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.
"Revisiting the Colwell Construction in Light of Mass/Count Nouns" by
Donald E. Hartley Th.M, Ph.D (student), Dallas Theological Seminary.
2. Don Hartley's Misunderstanding of My View of Qualitative Nouns and P. B.
Harners JBL Article By Greg Stafford
3. Hartley responds with "Hartley's Second Response To Stafford" on May
25, 1999.
4. Partial Response to Hartley, By Stafford: 5/25/99
5. Another Response to Stafford - 5/25/99 (third)
6. Greg Stafford on 5/26/99 says: "Hartley's theory, regardless of what he
tells you, is hopelessly without substantiation, as I will explain shortly."
7. Greg Stafford to Hartley on 5/26/99: "Please cite an example of a
singular count noun in the precopulative position, that CANNOT be indefinitized."
in Clarity, Please...
8. Specifically...I would like Hartley to list the 19 Q-class nouns to
which he refers on page 65 of his thesis (par. 2, line 5), for our
consideration.
9. Greg Stafford on 6/3/99: Surrejoinder to Don Hartley:
Q-Class Count
Nouns , John 1:1c, and Other Related Matters